Our Blog

Cr12MoV Steel – Application and Failure in Thread Rolling Die

Cr12MoV Material is a high-carbon high-chromium cold work tool steel (C: 1.45~1.70%, Cr: 11.00~12.50%, Mo: 0.40~0.60%, V: 0.15~0.30%). It has high hardenability, high wear resistance and certain red hardness, so it is widely used for making thread rolling dies. Its normal working hardness is controlled at 59～62 HRC. It is suitable for rolling low-carbon steel screws, high-strength bolts and other parts. However, Cr12MoV steel has an obvious shortcoming in toughness. If raw material or heat treatment is not well controlled, thread rolling dies will suffer early failure easily.

Table of Content

Hot product

Cr12MoV Steel
Cr12MoV Material
Cr12MoV

Application Features of Cr12MoV Steel in Thread Rolling Dies

Thread rolling dies work under severe cold extrusion / rolling, high contact stress, high cycle times, friction wear and local temperature rise. During thread rolling, the contact pressure on die teeth is much higher than common cutting work. The die needs these properties:

  1. High hardness and high wear resistance (from many eutectic carbides in matrix plus martensite matrix; hardness ≥60 HRC after quenching and tempering)
  2. High compressive strength and balanced strength and toughness (to resist chipping and spalling)
  3. Good hardenability and small heat treatment distortion (thread rolling dies have precise thread shape. Volume change after quenching is about 0.1~0.3%, much less than ordinary high carbon steel)
  4. Good resistance to repeated impact fatigue (bolt rolling runs tens of thousands of cycles).

Main Failure Modes of Thread Rolling Die in Cr12MoV Steel

Common failures of Cr12MoV steel thread rolling dies include:

  1. Chipping of teeth: The most common early failure. Partial spalling or fracture at thread cutting edges.
  2. Through cracking: Full or partial through cracks appear, and the die is scrapped directly.
  3. Collapsed & piled teeth: Threads deform and collapse due to softening from over-tempering.
  4. Early wear: Threads wear too fast, service life is shorter than expected.
  5. Double-pointed thread: Rolled threads show double-point shape, this is precision failure.

Failure Causes of Cr12MoV Steel

Eutectic Carbide Segregation in Cr12MoV Steel

Cr12MoV is ledeburitic steel. Plenty of eutectic carbides form during solidification. If the bar stock is not modified by repeated upsetting and drawing forging, carbides distribute in network / band segregation. They break matrix integrity and become fatigue crack sources. The eutectic carbide unevenness reaches Grade 5 (GB/T 14979 standard requires ≤ Grade 4 for this size).

Improper Heat Treatment Processes

  • High quenching temperature + long holding time: Thread tooth thickness is only 0.5~2.0 mm. Long heating at high temperature causes grain growth and overheating on teeth, and increases tooth surface spalling.
  • Direct loading into high-temperature furnace without full preheating: Cr12MoV has poor thermal conductivity. The temperature difference between inside and outside creates large structural stress and triggers internal microcracks.
  • Insufficient tempering / too low tempering temperature: Retained austenite cannot fully transform, and stress is not fully released. Microcracks start and spread during use. For example, thread rolling dies with vacuum quenching at 1020℃ + two tempering cycles at 140℃ for 5h, hardness 62.3 HRC, fail after rolling only 200 pieces. Microcracks widely appear on the teeth.

Use and Operation Factors

No lubrication makes tooth tip temperature rise rapidly. The temperature exceeds the tempering range of Cr12MoV steel. It softens threads and causes collapsed or piled teeth. Too large feed rate, too high rotating speed, uneven workpiece hardness, mixed hard quenched parts, heavy machine vibration or wrong alignment will worsen chipping and wear.

Failure Analysis Measures of Thread Rolling Dies in Cr12MoV Steel

  1. Macro inspection: Check chipping positions and crack paths. Cracks starting at stress concentration areas such as sharp corners or tooth roots suggest process stress problems.
  2. Chemical composition and hardness test: Confirm whether steel grade and quenched-tempered hardness meet design requirements. Thread rolling dies normally require 58~62 HRC.
  3. Metallographic analysis: Etch samples with 4% nital solution for grading. Items include eutectic carbide unevenness (GB/T 14979), network carbide, austenite grain size, retained austenite content and decarburized layer.
  4. Fracture SEM analysis: Judge brittle fracture type by cleavage or intergranular feature, and find fatigue sources. Carbide particles, folds and grinding cracks are common crack starting points.
  5. Check blind spots in testing: Magnetic particle inspection has uncertainty for high alloy steel. Linearly distributed carbide segregation and inclusions may be mistaken for cracks. Metallographic test is needed for confirmation.

Improvement Measures of Cr12MoV Material

Raw Material and Forging

  • Bar stock with sufficient modified forging (repeated upsetting and drawing) must be used to break and disperse eutectic carbides, and control unevenness ≤ Grade 4. For large forgings, high-temperature diffusion plus controlled rolling can reduce carbide unevenness from Grade 4 to Grade 2.
  • Spheroidizing annealing shall be carried out after forging (for example, hold at 860℃ for 2h, furnace cool to 750℃, then slow cool) to prepare microstructure for machining and final heat treatment.

Heat Treatment

  • Multi-stage preheating (such as two-stage preheating at 650℃ and 850℃) → oil quenching or vacuum gas quenching near 1030℃. Temper promptly after quenching to prevent residual stress build-up.
  • Sufficient tempering: Avoid tempering at too low temperature. Normally use about 200℃ × 2h for 2~3 cycles. When hardness above 60 HRC is required, cryogenic treatment at -120℃ ×4h can be added to promote transformation of retained austenite.
  • Austempering for strength and toughness: After austempering at 980℃×30min + 250℃×20min, the service life of thread rolling die increases by 22 times.
    The tooth profile should be formed by cutting to prevent fold cracks from cold rolling.

Surface Strengthening

Nitriding, nitrocarburizing (with titanium catalysis), TiN coating and other methods can greatly improve the tooth surface wear resistance and anti-seizure property of Cr12MoV steel, and extend service life.

FAQ of Cr12MoV Steel

Q1: Why does eutectic carbide segregation of Cr12MoV steel cause tooth chipping of thread rolling dies?

A: Carbides in Cr12MoV steel distribute in network or band shapes. They break the continuity of the matrix and become sources of fatigue cracks. When the grade exceeds Grade 4, cracks first form at carbide interfaces on the teeth under cyclic contact stress and lead to tooth chipping.

A: The tooth thickness of Cr12MoV steel is only 0.5–2.0 mm. Long heating at high temperature leads to coarse grains and overheating, which increases brittleness of the tooth surface. The surface layer easily spalls under high contact stress during rolling.

A: Insufficient tempering of Cr12MoV steel leaves retained austenite not fully transformed and internal stress unreleased. Microcracks start and grow during service. For example, after quenching at 1020°C plus two tempering cycles at 140°C for 5h, the hardness reaches 62.3 HRC, but the die fails after rolling only 200 parts.

A: After austempering at 980°C×30min + 250°C×20min, Cr12MoV steel gets mixed microstructure of lower bainite and martensite with better balance of strength and toughness. Its service life is 22 times longer than that of conventional quenching.

A: Cryogenic treatment at -120°C×4h promotes the transformation of retained austenite into martensite in Cr12MoV steel. It reduces microstructure change during use and improves hardness uniformity and dimensional stability. It suits dies requiring hardness above 60 HRC.

A: Nitriding, nitrocarburizing or TiN coating forms a hard low-friction layer on the tooth surface of Cr12MoV steel. It lowers friction coefficient, prevents cold welding and seizure, and greatly improves wear resistance and anti-seizure performance.

Conclusion

Cr12MoV steel for thread rolling dies has a core conflict: its high wear resistance perfectly matches rolling working conditions, but brittleness from ledeburite carbides conflicts with high cyclic contact stress on the teeth. Therefore, the key control points are: qualified modified forged raw material (carbide grade ≤ Grade 4) + full preheating and proper quenching and tempering process (austempering or cryogenic treatment if needed) + cutting forming of tooth profile + full stress relief by grinding. If necessary, add surface nitriding or coating, and the service life of thread rolling dies can rise by one order of magnitude.

More Cr12MoV Steel Resources

  1. 📩 Contact Keyspark Steel now if you need →

    📧 Email: Sales@keysparksteel.com

    📱 Mobile/WhatsApp: +86 150 2405 6480

    These are our related articles if you want to learn more tool steel comparison:

    1. Why is Cr12MoV Material Generally Supplied Annealed?

Related Posts